At the Table or On the Menu?

At the Table or On the Menu?

By Dee Taylor-Jolley

Here’s the good news: what we do locally doesn’t stay local. Our voices travel farther than we think.

Political scientists call it “policy diffusion.” That’s a fancy term for a basic reality: when one city or county tries something that works, other places copy it. And before long, state and federal leaders are paying attention.

Researchers Shipan & Volden showed how local anti-smoking ordinances spread from city councils to state capitols through learning, competition, and good old-fashioned advocacy. Once larger cities got engaged, they often pushed back against state attempts to shut them down and instead helped move statewide change forward.

Justice Louis Brandeis said in a 1932 Supreme Court dissent, that states are “laboratories of democracy.” I’d like to add that neighborhoods, ANC districts, and city wards are the “petri dishes” inside those labs. We get to test solutions close to home, without risking the whole country. And then we share what works.

Translation: your little “neighborhood issue” might be the pilot project that eventually becomes national law. That’s a wow!

Local Action Can Build Trust

We’re living in a time when trust is low and tempers are high. Yet new research shows that when people act on local issues, not just talk about them, it’s tied to higher trust in each other and in our institutions. That’s powerful.

Democracy doesn’t just need new laws. We need to heal relationships. Showing up together for traffic safety, school funding, or housing issues can strengthen our social relationships.

And our participation even changes who shows up at the polls. Pew Research’s 2024 analyses show that shifts in turnout among specific groups - young voters, people of color, suburban women - changed the national election outcomes.

That’s the proof that organized local engagement rippled all the way up to the White House.

“Little Ordinances” to National Shifts

Still not convinced your voice matters?

Researchers have tracked three different anti-smoking policies that started in cities and then bubbled up to the state level.

Local ordinances created:

  • New norms: “We don’t smoke in restaurants here.”
  • New data: reported health outcomes.
  • New political incentives: Leaders realized their voters liked the change.

State governments eventually adopted those same protections.

This same pattern is playing out right now on issues like climate, transportation, and public safety. When a city paints a bus-only lane, designs a traffic-calming plan, or changes emissions standards, it creates a new model and citizens may fight to keep and/or expand it.

Though, I must admit, I don’t like the adoption of the “white cones” to slow down control traffic flow in Washington, DC. They are ugly and have removed much needed parking spaces. Well, I lost that battle!

Local information and local news matter

When I was knocking on doors as a Commissioner, I noticed something: people who knew what the ANC and the school board were doing asked sharper questions, and I believe made better decisions at election time.

That observation is backed up by research. Communities with strong local news that’s funded, read, and defended by engaged citizens had:

  1. Higher voter turnout
  2. Less political polarization
  3. Greater accountability from leaders

When citizens know what’s really happening, they build a habit of checking facts not chasing outrage. And that habit shows up at the ballot box and, over time, influences national decision-making.

But note, local “laboratories” are not perfect. Scholars remind us that cities and states can suffer from resource gaps and political games. But even the critics agree that “subnational” policy shapes the national agenda, especially when we citizens keep showing up.

Our “home voice” still travels

You say, “Dee, I’m busy.” I know.
But here’s how you can do something.
You may not have time to sit on a board or read every 200-page report. I get it. But you can still do something.

Here are 5 doables :

  1. Serve as a poll worker.
    Elections don’t run by magic. The U.S. Election Assistance Commission and your local Board of Elections are always looking for people. Many jurisdictions pay poll workers. You get that front “row seat” to democracy and help protect the process.
  2. Use public comments – shrewdly.
    Councils, boards, and commissions must take public comment. Learn your city’s rules (time limits, sign-ups, written testimony) and show up… especially on that issue that’s been bothering you for years! Don’t fuss at the TV. Put your concerns on the record.
  3. Support local information.
    Support a local newsroom, podcast, or civic newsletter. Share accurate notes from meetings. Correct misinformation – gracefully! The link between local news and healthy democracy is broken by misinformation.
  4. Be the Bridge from Local to National.
    Groups like the National League of Cities offer toolkits that show how local stories become national. Find out from them how it’s done. And ask if there are funds to help you do that!
  5. Organize a tiny coalition.
    We don’t need a 500-person march. We need three committed people:
    • One data person - finds the facts and numbers
    • One storyteller - speaks and writes well
    • One connector – a relationship-builder who can put officials and neighbors together.

Please, work one issue at a time.

For example: We needed a stop sign at 13th and Madison Streets, NW. There was an accident at that corner almost weekly. The official city study said it was not needed.

As the Advisory Neighbor Commissioner, I got then Mayor Fenty to walk our neighbor one evening. He had been our Council Member before becoming Mayor. We had a relationship.

Would you believe there was an accident at that corner while we were taking our walk?!!

That stop sign is there right now!

Smart Strategy is Civic Engagement

This isn’t just about being a “good citizen.” It’s about being a wise steward of our business and our influence!

Research shows that companies embracing civic engagement strategies are:

  1. 6.5% more profitable
  2. Experience 2.2% higher revenue growth
  3. Are viewed as more valuable than companies that appear indifferent.

Active participation can opens doors to contracts and partnerships, build trust with customers and regulators and strengthen our reputation as a long-term, community-minded partner.

In other words, civic involvement isn’t just noble, it’s great for business!

Here’s The Bottom Line

National politics can feel confusing and exhausting. But the direction of our country is being written every day in city halls, school board rooms and volunteer tables at the polling places.

When we engage locally with focus, faith, and facts, we don’t just fix potholes… we’re paving the road for ideas to travel to the statehouse and all the way to the White House.

So, good neighbors, here’s my Dee challenge for you:

  1. Don’t watch democracy - work it!
  2. Don’t complain about what “they” did. Decide what you will do.
  3. Make sure you, your family, your church, and your business are at that table and not on the menu!

No involvement is too small. Do something!

Resources:

  1. Shipan, Charles R., and Craig Volden. “Bottom-Up Federalism: The Diffusion of Antismoking Policies from U.S. Cities to States.” American Journal of Political Science 50(4), 2006.
  2. Brandeis, Louis. Dissent in New State Ice Co. v. Liebmann, 285 U.S. 262 (1932).
  3. Pew Research Center – “Election 2024” and “Voter Turnout in the 2020 and 2024 Elections.” (2025)
  4. “Civic Engagement Seems to Be Good for Big Business.” The Fulcrum, 2022.
Dee Taylor-Jolley headshot

Dee Taylor-Jolley is the COO of Willie Jolley Worldwide. She provides back office operational strategies that help small businesses maximize their profits.